PBT and PET sit next to each other on the material selector’s chart, share the same polyester backbone, and are often quoted at similar prices. Engineers treat them as interchangeable more often than any other pair in electronics moulding. They are not. The difference in crystallisation rate alone changes cycle time, warpage, and dimensional stability enough to decide whether a co
ector moulds reliably on a 25-second cycle or fights flash and sink for a month.
The Structural Difference That Drives Everything
Both are semicrystalline thermoplastics built from terephthalic acid and a diol. PBT uses 1,4-butanediol; PET uses ethylene glycol. The shorter, stiffer butylene unit allows PBT to crystallise far faster — typically reaching useful crystallinity in a few seconds inside the mould, while unmodified PET may need 20–30 seconds plus a hot mould to reach the same state.
Consequences
- Cycle time: PBT parts demould hot and stable; PET wants a mould at 90–120 °C or more, and cooling dominates the cycle.
- Warpage: slow, uneven crystallisation in PET produces differential shrinkage — a classic warped PET co
ector housing.
- Glass-fibre grades: adding 30% glass fibre to PET shifts the balance, narrowing but not eliminating the difference. Many “PET vs PBT” arguments are really about glass-filled grades, where both perform well.
Property Comparison for Electronics Parts
Mechanical and thermal
Unfilled PBT and PET have comparable tensile strength around 50–60 MPa and similar HDT near 60–70 °C. With 30% glass fibre, both reach 130–160 MPa and HDT well above 200 °C at 1.8 MPa, comfortably passing through SMT reflow conditions if properly stabilised. PBT-GF30 typically shows slightly better ductility and impact than PET-GF30 at room temperature; PET holds stiffness better at elevated temperature.
Moisture and hydrolysis
This is where real-world failures live. Both polyesters hydrolyse when processed wet: moisture in the melt cleaves the polymer chain, and the part loses impact strength without any visible defect. Drying is mandatory for both — typically 120 °C for 3–4 hours for PBT, and sometimes higher or longer for PET. Parts with high regrind content need drying discipline enforced daily, not occasionally.
In service, PET has an edge in creep resistance and in resistance to some solvents. PBT better tolerates hot water and alkaline detergents, which matters for appliance and medical housings.
Electrical and flammability
Both offer good dielectric strength and are available in UL94 V-0 grades using halogen-free phosphorus or nitrogen systems, or brominated systems for cost-sensitive markets. Compare comparative tracking index values: V-0 PBT grades typically reach CTI 500–600 V, and high-CTI PET grades are available too. For a part that must pass a household or industrial IEC 60335 evaluation, the CTI number usually decides the grade, not the base polymer.
Where Each Wins in Practice
Choose PBT for
- Co
ector bodies, bobbins, coil formers
with thin walls and tight tolerances — fast crystallisation gives stable dimensions and short cycles. - Relay bases and switch housings where impact and dielectric strength combine.
- Anything with a thick-to-thin transition: PBT is more forgiving of differential shrinkage.
- Small parts at high cavitation counts, where cycle time is the whole cost equation.
Choose PET for
- Structural parts needing stiffness and creep resistance at elevated temperature, such as supports and brackets.
- Parts exposed to oils and automotive fluids, where PET’s solvent resistance is stronger.
- Applications already using recycled PET streams, where sustainability targets favour the material; expect to verify crystallisation behaviour and drying carefully.
- Large, simple-geometry parts where a hot mould and longer cycle are acceptable and stiffness per kilogram matters.
The Plating and Metal-Insert Question
For parts that need plated metal inserts, selective plating, or EMI coatings, surface chemistry matters. Both accept electroless nickel and copper plating after etching, but PBT’s faster crystallinity gives more consistent surface morphology, and therefore more consistent plating adhesion. If a part must be plated for EMI shielding, PBT is the safer base unless your plating house has qualified a specific PET grade — and insist on a peel test rather than a visual check.
Moulding Settings That Differ
PBT baseline
Melt 240–265 °C, mould 60–80 °C, injection speed moderate with profiled packing. Glass-filled grades want faster fill to avoid flow marks and slightly higher mould temperature for surface quality.
PET baseline
Melt 270–290 °C, mould 100–130 °C for crystallising grades, and expect to slow the cycle. Ru
ing PET in a cold mould produces amorphous, brittle parts that will fail dimensional checks after a
ealing — a classic and expensive mistake.
Tooling implications
PET’s higher mould temperature means more heater capacity, better insulation on the tool, and sometimes a different steel selection for thermal fatigue. Budget the tooling difference honestly; it is larger than the pellet price difference.
Cost Model Beyond the Pellet Price
PBT generally costs slightly more per kilogram than PET, but the pellet price is rarely the deciding number. Build the comparison on delivered cost per good part:
- Cycle time difference — often 15–30% in favour of PBT on thin walls.
- Warpage and rejection rate — PET’s crystallisation sensitivity raises first-pass reject rates until the tool is tuned.
- Mould temperature energy consumption.
- Drying time and dry-air dryer capacity.
- Regrind tolerance — PBT typically accepts 15–25% regrind with less property loss; PET’s higher processing temperature degrades regrind faster.
For a 30,000-part a
ual volume with a 20% cycle time penalty, PET’s lower pellet price is usually erased. For a low-volume structural bracket, PET is often the better and cheaper answer.
Selection Checklist
Before locking a grade, confirm: required HDT at the actual SMT peak and time above liquidus; UL94 rating at the wall thickness you will mould, not the thickness on the datasheet; CTI target for the applicable safety standard; dimensional tolerance and warpage budget; regrind policy; drying specification from the supplier’s processing guide; and the mould temperature your tool can actually achieve in the plant where it will run.
That last point is where most PET projects fail: a tool designed for 80 °C that must run at 120 °C. Match the polymer to the tool and the plant, and the PBT-versus-PET decision becomes straightforward rather than a matter of taste.